You will be redirected in
40
 seconds
 
StudentDC.com © 2015 | 5150 Palm Valley Rd. Suite 103 | Ponte Vedra Beach, FL 32082 | P:800.533.4263 F:904.285.9944
 
studentdc logo
July 22, 2007
Article Tools

Signing a non-compete agreement
By Jean Murray, PhD

A non-compete agreement is probably the most controversial part of any contract. It’s very difficult to set a general rule and courts won’t enforce the agreement unless it’s “reasonable.”

Let’s first discuss the general terms of a non-compete agreement. This part of an employment contract is designed to protect the hiring doctor in case you decide to leave and you “steal” his or her patients.

Non-compete agreements usually take the form of a restriction on three factors:

  1. Scope of activity (practicing chiropractic vs. practicing a specific technique),
  2. Related Articles

    1. Prepare a resumé or CV with a cover letter 
    2. Private practice vs. employment 
    3. Signing a non-compete agreement 
    4. Becoming an independent contractor 
    5. Finding an associate position 
    6. Evaluating an associate contract 
    7. Finding a job in chiropractic 
    8. The way of the champion 
    9. Don’t send out that BARE resume! 
    10. What does a successful associate look like? 
    Range of activity (prohibiting practice within a certain radius from the practice), and
  3. Period of restrictions (length of time).

WHAT’S REASONABLE?

Here’s where it gets tricky: What is a “reasonable” restriction? Most of these agreements broadly restrict “practice of chiropractic.” In regard to time period, in most cases, two years or less would be considered a “reasonable” time to prohibit you from practicing.

The distance restriction is more problematic, since it depends on the area. In an area that has a lot of people, such as a suburb, the area of restriction might be no more than five miles. In a rural area, the restriction might be as much as 25 miles.

Non-compete agreements are written based on the concept of “restraint of trade.” If the non-compete unreasonably restricts the former employee’s ability to practice (that’s restraint of trade), it isn’t going to be upheld. If the former employee merely engages in “ordinary competition,” that is, the same level of competition as any other chiropractor setting up practice in the area, prohibiting the former employee from practicing is unreasonable.

On the other hand, if it can be proven that the former employee took patient files and solicited patients, that’s unfair to the former employer and goes beyond “ordinary competition.” (Clear so far?)

So how do you know what’s reasonable? That’s the problem; you don’t. Let’s say you have signed a non-compete agreement that says you can’t practice chiropractic for two years within 25 miles of the other doctor, and you are in Golden, Colo. Technically, if you decide to set up practice in Boulder (a little more than 20 miles away), you may be in violation of the contract.

The way this is decided is through a court case. This means that you would move to Boulder and set up practice. The other doctor would see that you’ve done this, and he would get the court to issue an injunction against you, shutting you down, and prohibiting you from practicing and damaging his practice, until this is settled.

This might take months, if not years. The case goes to court, and the judge or jury make the determination of whether to uphold the non-compete, based on whether they think it unreasonably prohibits you from practicing.

Even if you win, you lose, because you’ve been shut down; you have many attorney fees to pay; and you have to rebuild your practice.

You may have heard that non-compete agreements are illegal. That’s not true. They are just very difficult to enforce. Courts decide enforceability on a case-by-case basis, and the burden of proof is on the former hiring doctor to prove that the non-compete is not unreasonable.

The best recourse is to go into an associate contract knowing that you’ll have to move far away from this practice when you leave. If the non-compete is 25 miles, double the distance to 50 miles. Play it safe.

Some examples of articles from attorneys on this issue:

• Non-Competition Contract, Trade Secret Lawyer, Attorney, Law Firm: tcattorney.typepad.com/noncompete/ (Michigan)

• Non-Compete Agreements in Texas - FAQ Smith Robertson Trial and Litigation Practice Group: smith-robertson.com/Litigation/FAQ%20Non-compete.htm (Texas)

• Are Non-competition Agreements Enforceable in Colorado Newsletters and Articles: rothgerber.com/newslettersarticles/el009.asp (Colorado)

• Employer-Employee Non-Compete Agreement in Florida, By Donald J. Spero, Esq.: floridamediationgroup.com/articles/spero/2000_Employer_employee_non
-compete_agreements_in_florida.html
(Florida)

To find out about non-competes in your state, go to Google and type in “non compete agreement” and the name of your state.

Find us on facebookFind us on Twitter
StudentDC Expert Insights
34
Perry Chinn

Chiropractic Gets Results

1/18/2015
(The following as submitted to the Plexus, the journal of the Washington State Chiropractic Association) The above title may appear so... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
16
Kelly Robbins

When One Door Closes Another One Opens -- But the Hallway Sure Sucks!

1/16/2015
When One Door Closes Another One Opens -- But the Hallway Sure Sucks!   As December moves along into January... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
47
Anthony Lombardi, DC

Influencing Other Professions: Jason Lomond OT interviews Anthony Lombardi DC

1/11/2015
  Guest: Written by Jason Lomond, OT: Over my career Ive made it a habit of learning from others, particularly those... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
58
Josh Wagner

How Referrals Really Work

1/05/2015
... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
21
Mark Sanna, DC

HCR Update from Mark Sanna:

1/31/2014
The N.F.L. said that the number of concussions in the league had declined 13% this season thanks to improved... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
29
Daniel Sosnoski

Live at Parker Las Vegas 2014

1/11/2014
We're here at the Parker Seminars conference in Las Vegas. The Chiro Eco staff are meeting old friends and... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
37
Shawne Duperon

Twitter - Hashtag Tips to Help Get Re-Tweeted

1/07/2014
Increase your Twitter Engagement. Tips that really work...   http://youtu.be/XcJ3DzFLQK0  ... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
46
Zach Zavoral

Twitter for Chiropractors

1/22/2013
How many people have suggested you start a Twitter page for your chiropractic office? Do you get a daily... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
25
Dr. Drew Stevens

Chiropractic Marketing Coaches

1/31/2012
The age of the Internet has allowed many to make claims about who they are and they work they... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
35
Julie Weaver

When Your Patients Stare at You...

1/31/2012
This has happened to all of us - at one time or another... You thought you communicated a clear... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
39
Jamie Phillips, DC

Chiropractic Marketing Tip #6: Don't Fight a Bad Rewiew

1/21/2012
Today we have a great chiropractic marketing tip. Don't waste your time defending your clinic when you receive... Read More
comments(2)
36
Dr Joe DiDuro

Almonds Can Improve Diabetes Control

1/10/2012
http://www.diabetesincontrol.com/articles/diabetes-news/11547-almonds-can-improve-diabetes-control Two new studies into the potential health benefits of eating almonds have supported evidence that they can help people... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
22
Richard Barwell, DC

Barwell responses to Dr D'Ambrosio,

1/25/2011
Hi Dr. D'Ambrosio, I loved your response, especially the fact that you consider yourself to be a Principled Chiropractor, as... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
5
Dr. Perry

Core Stability and Strength

1/26/2010
Here is a posting from my good friend Joe Heiler, PT. A brilliant clinician. Enjoy. Core... Read More
comments(3)
20
Lisa Roberts

Nutrition and Chiropractic Care

1/08/2010
Today, more than ever, there is increased awareness regarding proper nutrition. As a chiropractor, interested in improving the overall... Read More
Be the first to comment on this entry
2
Jean Murray

Who Pays the Taxes for an Independent Contractor?

1/09/2009
I've talked before on this blog about the issue of independent contractor vs. employee, and the problem of calling... Read More
comments(1)
4
Kevin Wong

Electives Really Aren't!

1/27/2008
Are you a little confused by the title of this blog post?  Let me explain.  It is my undying quest... Read More
comments(10)
Featured Videos

Buyer Beware
2/8/2012
Who should you trust? Do your research on seller history and testimonials!


Chiropractic marketing success
2/8/2012
Dr. Drew Stevens discuss chiropractic marketing success.


Building a brand
2/8/2012
The importance of having a personal brand


Additional Videos
Recent Job Openings
Associate Doctor
Chalmette, LA1/20/2015

Associate Doctor ... More

Dean of Clinics
Pasadena, TX1/09/2015

Founded in 1908, Texas Chiropractic College is the fourth oldest chiropractic college in the nation and recognized ... More

Associate
Jacksonville, FL1/07/2015

Interested in creating your vision of a practice within our locations? You will learn from a DC who has built thriving practices, yet you’ll have the freedom to implement processes ... More